It is not only the Buddha birthplace, Lumbini of present day Nepal Tarai, which has been brought into question since 1928; those professors and other authors from Odisha are also found questioning about the actual location of the Bodhi Tree
under whose shade the Buddha had attained enlightenment. Those scholars following, Mahagatimbiya—Tissadatta, a Bhikkshu from Shri Lanka, who seems to have visited the Bodhi Tree site, think the tree being very close to an ocean and also think the view running parallel to those of the Chinese travelers. Those historians and authors also talk of
Majjhimdesh (मज्झिम देश). In Jatakas and Lalita Vistara the Buddha is said to have himself told he was born in Majjhimdesh or Majjhim Desh (मज्झिम देश) – the ‘middle country’ (मध्य देश) or Madhesh (मधेश). Therefore, some Nepalese political leaders from Madhesh have nowadays begun to say that the Buddha was born in Madhesh (मधेश) – not in Lumbini either. But where wasMajjhimdesh or Majjhim Desh (मज्झिम देश) ? I shall copy below few lines from my 2010 paper:
“Another less heard but interesting claim so far made by another Orissan scholar is that Buddha himself had said he was born in the “Majjhima Desha of Jambu Dwipa”. He argues the ‘Majjhima Desh’ of Jambu Dwip cannot be Nepal. Here the writer himself appears to be forgetting that Orrisa too, doesn’t happen to be in central India or ‘Majjhima Desh of Jambu Dwip’. Orissa is on the western edge of Bay of Bengal in the Indian subcontinent. It is not at the center of India. The writer quotes, “Edward J. Thomas
had clearly said that the Jatakas and Lalita Vistara described the words of Buddha himself in this connection” of his birth in the Middle Province of India.
Here the “Pali Majjhima-desha is a *small* area in Malla country near Lumbini”
– not in Orissa. It is called ‘Madhyadesha or modern Madesh”.Nepal’s Tarai is also known as ‘Madhesh’ which may look identical to Madhya Pradesh of India, but not any particular place in Orissa.”
In Parinibbana Sutta, the Buddha is written to have said four different places related to him: his place of birth, enlightenment, first sermon, and passing away would be places of future pilgrimage. The Buddha birthplace is naturally a place of great importance to the Buddhist world today. So many scholars from India and Srilanka also sometimes wrongfully assert the Buddha being born to their respective countries. They seem to be either not taking seriously the present day Lumbini Ashokan inscription in Nepal Tarai or not accepting it at all.
Not only scholars from India or Shri Lanka, the western scholars also hesitate to attest Lumbini as the birthplace of the Gautam Buddha. They shrink back and write him “a native of the ancient Shakya republic
in the Himalayan foothills
” and who “taught primarily in northeastern India
. I think Nepal has to do something assertive about the Buddha birthplace which has remained long over due.
Again, while discussing the Buddha birthplace Lumbini, which lies in southwestern Nepalese Tarai today already mentioned above, historical records and archaeological evidence are what should be taken into account. It can’t be like “an old medievalist story about the fact that multiple Christian pilgrimage sites boasted of having the head of St. John the Baptist. The story goes that the issue was resolved by deciding that one site contained the head of St. John the Baptist when he was a young man and the other his head when he was an old man.” as Steve farmer, a bright Stanford neuro-biologist had posted to my query on the Buddha birthplace in 2009.
Furthermore, if we agreed with recent Lumbini excavation find as reported by Professor Robert Cunnigham, there was a pre-Ashokan brick temple already in Lumbini. He is reported as saying, “For the first time in South Asia, excavations have revealed a pre-Ashokan temple of brick, which itself was built over an earlier structure made of timber,”
We may also find some people doing ‘Buddha’s Birthday Education Project
to celebrate ‘the Buddha birthday’ but not telling where and when he was born exactly? The Buddha’s message of peace and nonviolence is important while observing his birthday but shouldn’t they be telling people in what exact location, that is to say in modern day Nepal’s Lumbini, where he was born ?
There are no exact dates so far when the Buddha was born. Some scholars believe he was born on April 8,543 B.C some other say it was May 15, 587 BCE Gregorian May 21, 586 Julian and a Nepalese Buddhist scholar says it should be May 15, 552 BC. The times of Buddha’s birth and death are uncertain. They vary from one historian to another.
The Hindu: Remains of pre-Ashokan shrines found in Lumbini
Celebration of The 2550th
anniversary of the Buddha. International Symposium and intercultural dialogue on Buddhist Contributions to Humanity and sustainable Development pf World Peace. October 7 to 9. 2006. UNESCO Headquarters, Paris France. http://www.amtb.org.tw/pdf/ch48-12-01.pdf
Amrit Ratna Tuladhar <email@example.com
>: Email communication September 16, 2013 : “To witness the tallying of Birth, Enlightenment and Death Day of LORD BUDDHA, the triple coincidence that took place within a cosmic period of 8 decades, I guess there occurs a difference of a complete day. Thus the 15th of May 552 B.C. and the 16th of May 507 B.C. both ought to be the 15th of May
. This is my thinking because Lord Buddha was born, got enlightened and passed away on the same Summer Full-Moon referred to as Vaisakh Purnima or Swanya Punhi, a thrice blessed auspicious occasion. This is a unanimous record without any doubt at all. The rest is fine !”
 The Buddha picture courtesy: Tricycle http://www.tricycle.com/feature/buddhas-birthplace